Passion and hatred

Kathy Sierra standing infront of slide saying ‘not rational’ 

 On Friday 6 April, Kathy Sierra posted a follow-up on the ‘death threats’ nightmare that began on 26 March when she was forced to cancel an appearance at the O’Reilly ETech conference. Here is the original post related to that.

As a high profile blogger, Sierra had been subject to criticism, including the occasional abusive post. The crucial difference was when the posts became overtly misogynist and began to threaten violence.

Similar posts threatened Maryam Scoble, and Sierra became so concerned for her own safety that the police became involved.

At first it appeared that several bloggers who had been critics of Sierra’s were responsible for the offensive comments. It later turned out that this blame was wrongly assigned with the offensive posts the work of still anonymous hackers, looking to stir up trouble between Sierra and her opponents.

One of those initially blamed Chris Locke, released a joint statement with Sierra on Monday 1 April to clarify some of this.

What is truly truly sad about all of this, which is highlighted in Sierra’s post on Friday is that she is now afraid to continue either her speaking engagements or her (fantastic) blog.

This is a talented author, speaker and incredibly insightful thinker. Sierra is not a politician or a pundit, she is advocate for a modern approach to brands and consumers in the electronic age.

How can we have rewarded her open, sharing and intelligent input with nothing less than an open-air mugging?

And, like all violent crime we leave a victim who will constantly be on the look out for the next attack. Her post from immediately after the incident said:

“I have cancelled all speaking engagements. I am afraid to leave my yard, I will never feel the same. I will never be the same.” 

The whole episode has perhaps left Sierra over-sensitised to misogny and hate, although it would be difficult not see those characteristics, particularly, lurking in the background of much of the IT industry.

Most galling is that there doesn’t seem to be a single thing we can do about it. No-one is defending the posts themselves because they were essentially acts of vandalism. This is not a free speech debate. This is not  a question of a blogging code of conduct.

The only answer can  be a zero-tolerance for abusive content and abusive motive. And if the hackers can be found, they should be treated no differently than if the threats had been sent by post or written on the outside of Sierra’s house.

Apart from that, all we can do is pray that Sierra has the courage to go on and does not loose faith in power of people to do good and help each other, and the role the web can play in enabling that.

1 thought on “Passion and hatred”

  1. Agree with you totally. One of the things that really shocked me about the whole affair, apart from the violent threats of rape and death to Kathy Sierra, was the fact that the general attitude of the blogosphere including I have to say smart folk like PSFK (with whom I had a long email conversation) was “live by the sword, die by the sword.” The idea that if you blog you open yourself up for abuse like this bewilders me. I had expected that bloggers would be up in arms, but they weren’t. Maybe there was a feeling that Kathy had got too big for her boots, maybe the fact the Scoble stopped blogging as support and people are fed up with him, muddied the waters a bit but it was quite depressing all in all.
    On a happier note, happy easter and hope that the new gig is going well!

Comments are closed.